Hey, do incentives matter… again?

In my latest National Post column I express dismay that yet another expansion of a social program, in this case EI, cost more than expected because paying people to do something caused more of them to do it. Of all things.

___________________________

To help support my work click here to contribute. (Note please that Patreon pledges are in U.S. dollars.)

The sweet smell of… freedom

In my latest National Post column I argue for marijuana legalization because free adults should make their own choices… and it is not always wrong to get high including on alcohol, nicotine or pot.

___________________________

To help support my work click here to contribute. (Note please that Patreon pledges are in U.S. dollars.)

You can’t just repeal bad laws, can you?

In my latest National Post column, I express frustration that Republicans can’t manage to get rid of Obamacare just because it’s a really bad law, and then go on and repeal more bad stuff.

___________________________

To help support my work click here to contribute. (Note please that Patreon pledges are in U.S. dollars.)

With government in charge…

In my latest National Post column I satirize people’s ongoing faith in government’s compassionate efficiency despite all their experience with its actual performance.

___________________________

To help support my work click here to contribute. (Note please that Patreon pledges are in U.S. dollars.)

He Lost It – It Happened Today, February 19, 2017

Should someone be excused a serious crime because they flipped out? I’m not referring here to a “not guilty by reason of insanity” plea, which I think virtually everyone concedes is sometimes legitimate. I mean the kind of mental imbalance that hits you suddenly and then recedes leaving you quite sane but also quite free.

I ask now because February 19 turns out to be the anniversary in 1859 of the first use of the “temporary insanity” plea in the United States. By a Congressman, no less, one Daniel Edgar Sickles, who had killed a son of the composer of “The Star Spangled Banner”. You see, Philip Barton Key II was having an affair with Sickles’ wife and Sickles, whose prior conduct was far from blameless (he married a girl half his age, then consorted openly with prostitutes while she was pregnant), got very annoyed and shot him.

It was a different era. The wealthy and privileged Sickles was apparently so popular that visitors streamed to see him in jail where, among other things, he was allowed to keep a gun. But his high-powered lawyers, including Edward M. Stanton who later served as Lincoln’s Secretary of War, convinced the public and the court that he was so angry at his wife’s infidelity that he was not responsible for what he did in his rage.

It may not have helped the prosecution that newspapers subsequently hailed Sickles for saving women from Key. But still, the case troubles me.

In theory I can see that you could take leave of your senses for various reasons including justified anger in ways that diminish or eliminate legal responsibility. But I’m not convinced I understand the difference between being so angry you shoot your wife’s lover and go to jail (or the gallows) and being so angry you shoot him and it’s OK. As a weird footnote, after making his wife’s cheating a huge public issue Sickles publicly forgave her, which evidently upset people a lot more than the original shooting.

Sickles went on to rise to Major General in the Civil War despite his notorious ambition, drinking and womanizing, eventually commanding III Corps, which he so mishandled at Gettysburg that the resulting action cost him his command (as well as his right leg) though not his commission. He spent years after the war arguing that his blunder had actually been a bold and well-advised strategic stroke and in 1897 he received the Congressional Medal of Honor for it, before ultimately dying in 1914 at age 94.

He was, it seems, a man of remarkably poor judgement in his personal and often public life. But the court ruled that his actual insanity was only temporary and absolved him of murder whereas it sounds to me as though in this case at least it was just a singularly spectacular and consequential display of lifelong lack of self-control.

 

___________________________

To help support my work click here to contribute. (Note please that Patreon pledges are in U.S. dollars.)

Tax and spend, never mend

In my latest National Post column I lament the latest New Brunswick budget continuing down the boringly disastrous path of deficits today for affordable free money the day after tomorrow… or after the next election… or never.

___________________________

To help support my work click here to contribute. (Note please that Patreon pledges are in U.S. dollars.)

Wish I’d said that – December 22, 2016

“The mark of civilization, says [Yale professor David] Gelernter, is the shortening of the list of reasons that justify taking human life. But now footnotes are being added to the list.”

Richard John Neuhaus in First Things January 2004

___________________________

To help support my work click here to contribute. (Note please that Patreon pledges are in U.S. dollars.)

Update, thanks and Merry Christmas to our documentary backers

Wrapping up 2016 and looking forward to 2017, a word of thanks to all those who made our documentary work possible in the past year.

___________________________

To help support my work click here to contribute. (Note please that Patreon pledges are in U.S. dollars.)