It happened today – June 24, 2016

On this date in 217 B.C., June 24, Hannibal Barca inflicted a crushing defeat on the Romans at the Battle of Lake Trasimene in central Italy. Along with his subsequent annihilation of an entire Roman army at Cannae, eight legions, between 48,000 and 70,000 men, it crushed Rome decisively.


As Victor Davis Hanson notes, the astounding thing about Rome is that the result of such defeats, long before it became a world power, was not collapse but fresh armies arising from the citizens one after another. Hanson has been criticized for his thesis about the superiority of the Western way of war, including because Hannibal did win these battles, forcing Rome to fight a long, defensive, harassing war, avoiding decisive conflicts and wearing Carthage out. But the fact is that they did wear Carthage out. And no amount of rationalizing can conceal the fact that for 2,500 years, wars between Western and non-Western nations have been absurdly lopsided.

Even the wars the West loses, like Vietnam, see enormously higher casualties on the other side.

The Punic War is a partial exception. At Trebia in 218 B.C., though numbers from ancient battles are notoriously unreliable, the Romans seem to have lost between five and seven times as many as the Carthaginians despite having superior numbers. At Trasimene itself, Hannibal had superior numbers coming in, and again his forces suffered perhaps one-sixth the casualties of the severely beaten Romans. At Cannae, the most perfect encirclement battle in history, it was 10 to one. (Curious coincidence: one of the Roman commanders at Cannae, along with the fatally impetuous Gaius Terentius Varro, was Lucius Aemilius Paullus. In the second most perfect encirclement battle in history, at Stalingrad in World War II, the losing commander was von Paulus. It doesn’t mean anything. It’s just weird.)

So here’s the thing. Why didn’t Rome collapse? Why were they able, after such losses on their own doorstep, estimated at one-fifth of all male citizens over 17, with southern Italy revolting and joining Hannibal’s cause, to raise fresh armies, slog on, and win?

Sure, details matter, including the wisdom of putting Fabius Maximum back in charge after Cannae to resume the delaying and harrying tactics that had so frustrated them that they’d let Varro rush into that disaster. And the reorganization of battle tactics to provide greater flexibility after Hannibal had repeatedly outmaneuvered their standard unwieldy formations. But all of this, the capacity to do it and the resilience to make it stick, have deeper roots.

If Trasimene had proved fatal to the Roman cause, along with Trebia and if necessary Cannae, it would be wholly unremarkable. That it did not is therefore necessarily remarkable. Something was different about Rome, something that is still different about the West.


Help me change #politics by changing the #culture. Click here to contribute. (Note, subscriptions are in US dollars.)

Wish I’d said that – June 24, 2016

“The fact on our side, to be held firmly, is that the tide against us is only a tide; that is, it is a dead thing. Its rapidity is all routine; whereas we, whether we win or drown, who build a dyke, are alive.”

G.K. Chesterton in New Witness April 26 1918, quoted in Gilbert Magazine Vol. 17 #4 (Jan.-Feb. 2014)


Help me change #politics by changing the #culture. Click here to contribute. (Note, subscriptions are in US dollars.)

“The” pill

My latest for the Rebel:

The first oral contraceptive pill, approved by the US FDA on June 23, 1960, had a far larger impact on the way we live than all the legislation and political agitation of that or many other years. As Andrew Breitbart was fond of saying, politics is indeed downstream from culture.

The audio-only version is available here:

Rebel audio, June 23 - Download This Episode


Help me change #politics by changing the #culture. Click here to contribute. (Note, subscriptions are in US dollars.)

It happened today – June 23, 2016

“How small, of all that human hearts endure, That part which laws or kings can cause or cure.” That’s from Samuel Johnson. And I wish it were engraved in legislatures and especially executive and judicial branch buildings. And taken to heart by too many who place faith in politics. Politicians don’t create parades, they only lead them. And the parades don’t originate in the political system at all.

Indeed, as Andrew Breitbart apparently originally said, “Politics is downstream from culture.” And, I dare say, from history. Because on this date in 1960, June 23, something happened that was far more important than the election of John Kennedy that November, his selection of Lyndon Johnson as his running mate, the antics surrounding John Diefenbaker, the looming prime ministership of Lester Pearson who brought Pierre Trudeau to Ottawa or any number of inspiring or infuriating things that made the headlines.

Specifically, the United States FDA approved “the pill.” There were a number of important pills in the 1960s, from Mick Jagger’s housewives’ “little yellow pill” to Augustus Owsley Stanley’s little purple one. But “the pill,” the one that supposedly let women have sex without consequences, turned the world upside down far more dramatically even than LSD.

It let all kinds of feminist theories become practice. With, I think, very mixed and often disastrous results. But there’s a difference between disliking something and pretending it didn’t happen or didn’t matter. The pill was invented, and approved, and gender relations changed in enormously important ways that we are all still struggling with today.

It didn’t make the headlines. But it made the history books. It’s often that way.


Help me change #politics by changing the #culture. Click here to contribute. (Note, subscriptions are in US dollars.)